This is the sixth in a series of “55-Plus” columns on courtroom reality shows. To read the previous columns on the subject, click here.

Continued from page one...

A 1989 poll conducted by the Washington Post showed that while only 9 percent of the members of the public could name the chief justice of the United States, 54 percent knew that Wapner was the judge on “People’s Court.”

In fact, his shows were aired around the globe.

How did Wapner land his television judgeship? He recounted during a recent interview that it stemmed from a conversation between one of the show’s executive producers, Ralph Edwards — host of the popular 1950s show, “This Is Your Life” — and then-Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Christian Markey (since retired). Wapner said that Markey, who had been his tennis partner for years at the annual judges’ tournaments, recommended him for the role.

As Markey recounted the conversation, Edwards, whom he termed a “dear friend,” offered the role to him. “I told him I could not do it as a sitting judge, and I was not about to retire,” he said. But Wapner had recently left the bench, and Markey suggested that Edwards contact him.

“He knew how to run a courtroom,” Markey said of his former colleague. “He was tough-minded.”
Markey did acknowledge that Wapner “could be abrupt,” but continued:

“He had a good wit. He knew how to smile. He knew how to treat people and conduct a court.”
Edwards took Markey’s advice.

Wapner recounted:

“Ralph called and he said, ‘I’m looking for a retired judge to play a judge doing small claims.’ This was a Friday afternoon. I just finished an arbitration. ... I talked to him for about three hours.”

He said that Edwards finally asked him:

“Will you do a case for me on Monday?”

He came to the production company’s office, he recalled, and presided over a case in which a woman, who was about five-feet tall, 100 lbs., was suing a six-foot man, who weighed about 275 lbs., for battery. These weren’t actors. Just as on the actual show that was being planned, “real people” were there with real disputes. Wapner conducted binding arbitration in a mock small claims court setting.

As Wapner recalled it, it was when he told the irate defendant to sit down and be quiet, in an authoritative tone, and the hulk complied, that the producers became impressed.

Actually, executive producer Stu Billett said, he was impressed when he first encountered Wapner that day.

“I thought — this was Tyrone Power,” he brought to mind. “What a great looking guy.”

After Wapner tested for the role, Billett said, he abandoned the idea of using alternating judges.

A pilot was made, with Wapner as the judge.

One night, it was screened in a small studio in Edwards’ home. Present were Edwards, Wapner, Markey and their spouses.

Markey told me:

“Everybody was fairly enthusiastic about it, except one Chris Markey.”

He explained:

“I thought it was crummy. It didn’t seem to me to be anything anybody would be interested in.”

Markey said he remembers commenting, “Ralph, it will never sell.”

He related:

“For years after, Ralph would remind me of that.”
Edwards, by the way, recently turned 90.

•      •      •

Next week: The networks rule incorrectly on the viewer appeal of “The People’s Court.”